Home / Guides / Shipping protection vs carrier claims

Shipping protection apps vs carrier claims: what a Shopify store actually needs

Shipping protection apps such as Route and ShipInsure charge the customer a fee at checkout and handle reorders when a parcel is lost. Carrier claims recover money from USPS, UPS or FedEx for the parcel you already paid to ship, at no extra cost per order. Many stores need both: protection for the customer experience, claims so the carrier pays for its own losses.

The options side by side

Who paysWho handles the claimWhat you get back
RouteThe customer, at checkoutRouteReorder or refund for the customer
ShipInsureThe customer, at checkoutShipInsureRefund or reorder for the customer
Navidium and other self-funded appsThe customer; you keep the feesYouWhatever you choose to cover, funded by the fees
Shipsurance via ShopifyFree up to $200 on eligible labels, or per labelYou file, Shipsurance paysThe insured value
Filing carrier claimsNo per-order costYou (or a tool like ConfirmShip)Item value and label cost, up to the carrier's coverage

Where protection apps fit

Protection apps make lost parcels painless for the customer. The trade-off is a fee on every order, which some shoppers untick, and claims that are judged by the app's terms rather than the carrier's.

Where carrier claims fit

Every USPS Priority Mail and Ground Advantage label carries built-in coverage, and UPS and FedEx accept claims too. The money is there, but the windows are short and the steps are fiddly, so most stores never file. That's the gap carrier-claim tools fill.

Using both

A store can use protection at checkout and still claim from the carrier for parcels the protection doesn't cover, or before it pays out of pocket. Don't claim the same loss twice: if Shipsurance or another insurer covers a label, claim there, not with the carrier.

What ConfirmShip does

ConfirmShip is a carrier-claims tool, not insurance. It watches every Shopify shipment, flags the lost and stuck ones, writes each claim and tells you where to file before the deadline. It's free up to 50 packages a month and doesn't add a fee at checkout. [Install free on Shopify]

Frequently asked questions

Is Route worth it for a Shopify store?

It depends on your margins and customers. Route is free to install and the customer pays for protection at checkout, with Route handling reorders. Some merchants value the time it saves; others report frustration with claims. Compare reviews on the Shopify App Store.

What's the difference between shipping protection and shipping insurance?

Shipping protection is usually a checkout add-on the customer pays for, run by an app. Shipping insurance, such as Shipsurance, covers a specific label's value and you file the claim.

Do I still need to file carrier claims if I use shipping protection?

Often yes. Protection apps reimburse the customer; the carrier still owes for parcels it lost. Claiming from the carrier recovers that money, as long as you don't claim the same loss twice.

Is there a free way to recover lost package costs on Shopify?

Yes. Carrier claims cost nothing to file, and eligible Shopify Shipping labels include up to $200 of Shipsurance coverage. ConfirmShip is free up to 50 packages a month.

Sources

Your next lost parcel already has a deadline.

Install ConfirmShip, and you'll know it before the window opens.

Free for most stores · $19.99/month only above 50 packages a month · Billed through Shopify

Step 1 · Add to Shopify

Get ConfirmShip on your store

We're finishing Shopify's App Store review. Tell us your store and we'll send a private install link.

Free up to 50 packages a month. We'll email your install link, usually the same day.